How it works

The short version: you sign in, you write one thing you hate and one thing you love, and both are checked before either appears. Most entries publish. The rest are turned away quietly, and a small number carry a penalty. This page explains all of it, including the parts that are inconvenient.

Signing in

Two ways in, and neither involves a password. You can continue with Google, or give an email address and get a one-time sign-in link sent to it — click the link and you're in. There's nothing to remember and nothing to leak.

Signing in is not about credit. It exists so the site can moderate what arrives, stop one person flooding the queue, and make a ban mean something rather than being shrugged off with a new account. Your entry publishes with no visible author, and nothing on the public page connects it to you.

While your entry is waiting to be reviewed, the server does know it's yours — it has to, because that's the point at which a decision gets made. At the moment it publishes, that link is deleted. Not hidden, not restricted to staff: deleted, in the same operation that makes the entry public. Afterwards nobody can say who wrote it, and that includes us. We can't look it up, we can't be persuaded to look it up, and we can't be compelled to hand over something we no longer hold.

What stays on your account is only the outcome: whether you've been warned, how many strikes you have, and whether you're banned. A number and a flag. Not a list of what you wrote.

The honest cost of that: once an entry is public, it can still be pulled, but nobody can be penalised for it — there's no longer anyone to penalise. Moderation has to do its work before publication, because afterwards there's nothing left to act on. That's the trade, and it's deliberate.

What's allowed

The whole rule, in one line: hating what someone does is fine, hating what someone is isn't.

So complaints about behaviour, situations, objects, weather, institutions in the abstract, your own bad habits, the specific way a thing is designed — all fine, and that's the great majority of what gets filed. A complaint about something that happens to be done mostly by one group is still about the behaviour, and still fine.

Your love entry can be sardonic. "I love it when a meeting gets cancelled" is a real entry and it publishes. It only gets held back if it reads as genuinely negative, in which case a person looks at it rather than a machine guessing.

Both boxes are required, 200 characters each, in English. An entry in another language is turned away with no penalty attached — it isn't a misconduct finding, the site just can't moderate what it can't read.

What isn't

Hate aimed at what someone is. Race, religion, sexuality, disability, gender, ethnicity. This is the one thing that carries a ban on a first offence. Political parties, diets, tastes and professions are not in this category — you can hate a political party here.

Naming a private individual, or describing one closely enough to identify them — "the landlord of the Red Lion in [small village]" counts even with no name in it. Rejected with a warning.

Naming a company, brand or organisation. Also rejected with a warning. This one catches people out, because it feels harmless to complain about a named firm's hold music. The reason is defamation: this site publishes anonymously, which means if a company objects to something written about it, there is no author to point to and the site carries it alone.

Published after review — with no promised turnaround

Nothing publishes on arrival. Entries are checked in three stages: an instant check against a list of unambiguous slurs at the moment you submit, an automated classification pass, and human review for anything the automated pass wasn't confident about.

There is no publishing schedule and no guaranteed turnaround. Review happens in batches rather than continuously, and anything routed to a person waits until a person actually gets to it. That might be hours; it might be considerably longer. Nothing is wrong if your entry hasn't appeared yet, and there's nothing to chase — this is a small archive run at a human pace, not a service with an SLA.

If an automated stage fails or errors, the entry goes to a human instead of being published. Uncertainty never resolves to "publish it and see."

You won't hear anything if it's rejected

There are no rejection notices. No email, no notification, no status page, no appeal form. The site has no way to contact you at all, by design — an entry that isn't approved simply never appears.

This is a deliberate trade and it does have a real cost: you can't tell a rejection apart from a queue that's still moving, and if something of yours was turned away you won't find out why. What you get in exchange is that Quite Human is never a thing that arrives in your inbox. It doesn't email you, doesn't notify you, and doesn't have a reason to hold your attention. If you'd like to know whether something published, come and look.

Warnings, strikes and bans

Three different outcomes, and they aren't the same:

A rejection with no penalty. Nothing is held against you. This is what happens to entries that simply can't be used — the wrong language, for instance.

A warning. The entry is rejected and you're on record, but no strike is counted. Naming a person or a company usually lands here.

A strike. Two strikes is a ban. Strikes do not expire and do not decay — there's no window after which the first one stops counting.

A direct ban. Hate targeting a protected characteristic bans on the first offence, with no strike counting involved.

All of these are decided before an entry publishes — that's the only point at which the site knows whose entry it is. A ban stops anything further from that account; it doesn't reach back through what's already public, because by then the link is gone.

One thing worth saying plainly, because it's the part people assume works the other way round: no penalty is ever applied by software alone. The automated pass can recommend a ban, but it cannot issue one. Every strike and every ban is confirmed by a person looking at the actual entry first — including the cases the system considers clear-cut.

If you're banned, you'll find out when you try to sign in and submit again. You'll be told, in a message that is not especially warm about it.